Changing Your Broker or Your Insurer

Changing your adviser and changing your insurance are two completely different things. Most of the anxiety around this comes from the two being confused.

Changing adviser

Broker of record letter

BOR

A signed instruction from the plan sponsor to the insurer appointing a new broker on an existing policy. It transfers servicing rights and commission. It does not change the contract, the rates, the insurer or the coverage.

Nothing about your coverage moves and nobody re-enrols. Your plan, your carrier, your rates and your members’ cards all stay exactly as they are. Only the adviser changes.

Agent of record

AOR

The same instrument under a different name, depending on insurer and jurisdiction.

Use whichever term appears on the insurer’s own form.

Incumbent

The broker currently servicing the plan.

Insurers usually notify the incumbent and allow a window to respond. Expect a call, and expect an offer. That is normal and not a reason to reverse course.

Commission and servicing fee

Commission is a percentage of premium built into the rate, varying by line — richest on health and dental, thinner on life and disability. A servicing fee is a flat negotiated amount replacing commission, disclosed to the client.

Commission sits inside retention, which means it is part of what you pay whether or not your broker does anything. Asking what your broker is paid is a fair question and a good one.

Changing insurer

Timing matters more than effort. Insurers quote meaningfully sixty to one hundred and twenty days before an effective date. Rates pulled nine months early are stale before anyone can use them.

Market pass

Taking a plan’s specifications to multiple insurers for competing quotes.

Deciding not to market is a legitimate outcome. A plan marketed into an unfavourable window can come back worse, and that costs more than it saves.

No-loss no-gain

A takeover provision under which the incoming insurer matches the prior plan’s treatment of members already disabled or absent — no coverage lost on the move, and none gained.

Ask for it in writing on any move involving anyone off work. Without it, an employee on leave can fall between two insurers with neither accepting responsibility.

Disclosure of disabled and absent employees

Members not actively at work on the takeover date must be individually disclosed to the incoming insurer.

Non-disclosure is the most serious error possible on a takeover. An insurer that learns at claim time of an undisclosed absent employee can rescind, leaving the employer with an uninsured liability.

Run-off period

The window after termination during which the prior insurer continues to pay claims incurred while their contract was in force — often ninety days for submission.

Tell members explicitly where to send claims from the weeks either side of a change. This is where the complaints come from on an otherwise clean transition.

Benefit maximum carry-over

Whether amounts already used in the year under the prior plan count against the new plan’s maximums.

Frequently overlooked. A member who has used their dental maximum may find it either reset or preserved — and either answer produces a phone call if nobody said which.

Before any move

Check for a pre-existing condition clause and for anyone currently under treatment or off work. Moving a disability line can mean a new insurer declines a claim the previous one would have paid. This is the single biggest risk in changing insurers, and it is entirely checkable in advance.

General information for Ontario group benefits — not advice on a specific plan. Contract wording and program eligibility vary and change. Health Life Value Consulting (HLVC) · FSRA-regulated through Alliance Income Solutions.

HLVC
HLVC

Engineered Health. How Canadian employers de-risk their workforce.

Harikaran Loganathan, B.H.Sc. (Kin), CSEP-CPT #26660, LLQP #26250965

647-459-1243

Office

  • Toronto, Ontario
    Canada
  • LinkedIn
  • hlvalueconsulting.ca
    hlvalueconsulting.com

DISCLAIMER · Exclusions apply. The 15% premium reduction is typical and applies to core benefits including dental and life insurance. The 15% discount is offered at the sole and complete discretion of HLVC Consulting and Alliance Income Solutions. Individual results vary based on plan structure, claims history, carrier, and underwriting. No outcome is guaranteed; figures shown are illustrative and based on representative engagements.

© 2026 Health Life Value Consulting (HLVC). All rights reserved.

PrivacyAccessibility (AODA)LLQP #26250965 · CSEP-CPT #26660

© 2026 HEALTH LIFE VALUE CONSULTING · All content, copy, methodology, valuation models, brand marks, and visual design on this site are the intellectual property of Health Life Value Consulting (HLVC) and are protected under Canadian and international copyright law. Unauthorized reproduction, redistribution, or derivative use — in whole or in part — is strictly prohibited without prior written consent. "HLVC", "Engineered Health", and the HLVC monogram are trademarks of Health Life Value Consulting.

Insurance Inducement Disclosure

Any non-insurance service described on this site is offered on its own stated terms. No such service is funded by, drawn from, added to, or provided as a rebate of any client's insurance premium. These services do not reduce, rebate, or vary the premium, terms, cost, coverage, or benefits of any insurance policy.

Appointing Harikaran Loganathan (LLQP #26250965) as Broker of Record transfers the servicing of a group benefits plan to HLVC; it is not the purchase, sale, replacement, or switching of an insurance contract or carrier. These services are not offered as an inducement to buy, replace, renew, or maintain any insurance product within the meaning of the insurance legislation of the applicable Canadian province (including, in Ontario, the Insurance Act and FSRA's Unfair or Deceptive Acts or Practices rule). Nothing here is insurance advice, a recommendation to buy or replace coverage, or a binding offer of insurance; all insurance-licensed (LLQP) activity is conducted under, and subject to, the requirements of FSRA and the applicable provincial insurance regulators of Canada.

HLVC is compensated by carrier commission as Broker of Record — no fee to the client corporation. Any tax discussion is illustrative only; confirm both corporate deductibility and possible employee taxable-benefit treatment with your accountant. Figures shown are illustrative and based on stated assumptions. HLVC: LLQP #26250965 · CSEP-CPT #26660 · B.H.Sc. (Kin) · Ontario-licensed Life & A&H insurance brokerage · Fully insured CGL.